Auditing Your Landlord's Books
When you receive the form lease from your landlord, you can expect to see a paragraph that requires you to pay your pro rated share of increases in taxes and insurance, charges for gas, electricity, etc., and your pro rata share of trash removal. You should have the right to review the landlord’s books and records to assure yourself that you’re not being overcharged by the landlord.
Although the lease might say that your landlord’s annual determination of expenses is binding, it should go on to give you, as the tenant, the right to review the landlord’s books and records supporting such determination.
I’ve seen leases that say you have the right to use an independent accountant to perform the review, but the accountant can't be compensated on a contingency basis. In addition, you may be given only 90 days within which to object. The problem with accepting a 90 day limitation is that it’s virtually impossible for most tenants to determine whether there's anything wrong within 90 days. You have to hire a lease audit firm to review the lease and the bills, you have to gather internal information, coordinate schedules for the audit, conduct an on-site review of the books and records, complete the analysis, prepare a report, and present the findings to the landlord. The result of this is that the necessary work just can't be done within 90 days, and so you can't meet the deadline. There should be an Addendum to the form lease giving you more than 90 days to get this done.
As far as who can help you with the audit, you should be able to use a contingency firm if you feel it would be in your interest. The landlord has no legitimate interest in telling you who you can hire. Certainly, the landlord wouldn't tell you what attorney to use and what your fee arrangement should be. The reason a contingency fee audit firm could be good for you is that you may not have the money needed to pay for an audit on an hourly basis. This means that even though you have the right to an audit, you generally will not exercise your right unless you can use a contingency fee firm.
By the way, a contingency firm is one that gets paid based on how much money they save you. If the audit finds you have not been overcharged by the landlord, there is no fee.
