December 1, 2009

It Hurts to Be Told You Aren't Hurt

As a Delaware personal injury lawyer who handles car accident cases, I always tell my clients that the number 1 rule is to tell the truth. Sometimes, telling the truth is not enough if your medical records don't support what you're saying. Here's a typical example of what happens

On 12/16/09, actress Anne Hathaway was in a minor traffic accident in Los Angeles. Newspaper accounts of the accident say that she was not injured. It would be interesting to talk to her a week after the accident to see how she’s doing. Why? because it's not unusual to be in a car accident and think you’re okay. You tell the cops that you aren’t injured, and you refuse medical treatment. That night, the next day, or even a few days later, you begin to feel pain or soreness. You think to yourself that it’s normal to feel some pain - after all, you were just in an accident. You go about your normal routine. If you’re lucky, the pain goes away completely. In some cases, however, the pain lingers. Once again, you assume that it’s only a minor injury and that you’ll return to normal in the near future.

You continue to hurt, you complain about the pain to your spouse, and you still don’t see a doctor. After a few months, you finally realize that this isn’t going away, and you reluctantly call your doctor’s office to schedule an appointment. After the medical exam, the doctor tells you that you have cervical (neck) and lumbar (back) strain and sprain, and that you need physical therapy and drugs.

At some point you think about making a claim for your injuries, and you contact the other driver’s insurance company. The claims representative takes your statement over the phone, gets your medical records, and tells you that you waited such a long time to see your doctor that it appears the pain you’re complaining about is not related to the accident.

So what should you have done? As soon as you start to feel symptoms of pain or soreness, get checked out by your doctor. There’s no harm in playing it safe. Your own car insurance company will pay for the visit. If it turns out that your doctor says “take 2 aspirins and call me in the morning,” consider yourself very fortunate that you weren’t injured and you don’t have a personal injury claim. On the other hand, if your doctor prescribes pain killers and muscle relaxants, or prescribes physical therapy, you’ve helped your personal injury claim because you got medical attention early on and your medical records will relate the symptoms to the accident.

It’s great to be stoic and put off seeing a doctor following an accident. Unfortunately, this way of dealing with things could come back to haunt you later on when the insurance company accuses you of being dishonest.

Bookmark and Share

October 30, 2009

Signed Releases From Liability Don't Always Matter

As a Delaware trial lawyer, I was recently called by an injured client who wanted to know whether she could file a lawsuit even though she had signed a release of liability. In her case, the answer was “yes.” A good example of this is a recent trial in Texas where a jury awarded $11.4 million to a boy who was seriously injured at a Texas Motor Speedway, a paved 1/5 -mile track designed for amateur adults and children as young as 8. The accident happened when another boy drove across the lot to enter the track, lost control of the car, narrowly missed a trailer and several parked cars and then slammed into the injured child as his parents, brother, and others watched. driving. He suffered a traumatic brain injury that’s so severe he will never live independently and will need help with basic daily tasks such as bathing, dressing and eating.

The boy’s parents signed releases that spelled out the risks and barred them from filing a lawsuit. Even so, the jury found that the race track should be held accountable because it did not provide barricades, signs, a kill switch on the car, and proper instructions to prevent an accident. After the trial, the Speedway added safety precautions to avoid future problems.

The moral of the story is that if you’re injured after you signed a release, you should consult with a Delaware attorney before you decide that you don’t have a case.

Bookmark and Share

July 6, 2009

Head Injuries

As a Delaware personal injury lawyer, it still makes my blood boil whenever a doctor who's been hired by an insurance company claims that my seriously injured client didn't really suffer what's known as a traumatic brain injury.

This is the first in a series of articles that will explain how and why this occurs, and what highly skilled attorneys for brain injured clients are doing about it.

Let's begin with an example of what I'm talking about. I represent a young woman who was severely injured in a car crash here in Delaware. One of her injuries was a traumatic brain injury. A well known psychiatrist was hired by the insurance company for the other driver, and he tested my client over 2 full days. After the testing, he issued a report that said, among other things, that my client could not have suffered a brain injury because her MRI and CatScan were normal, she didn't hit her head, and she didn't lose consciousness.

During my 8 hour deposition of this so-called medical expert, I asked a series of questions which resulted in typical hogwash responses. Rather than accepting whatever he said as gospel, I continued to press this expert witness until he finally told the truth. Here's a sample of what he said after a lot of questions.

He started with the statement that "Her MRI and her CAT scan demonstrated no clinical solid evidence of a trauma to her brain."

So I asked:
Q. Tell me what literature you rely on that supports the notion that a negative MRI and negative CAT scan rule out brain injury.
A. There is none.

And later on, I asked:
Q. Let me go back to the MRI and CAT scan, for just a moment. Would you agree that a person can have a normal CAT scan and a normal MRI and yet have a brain injury?
A. That's possible.

He also finally admitted that just like a baby can suffer "shaken baby" brain damage without ever hitting its head, an adult driver can also suffer a brain injury if their head is thrown forward and backward hard enough.

And upon still more questioning, he admitted that a person does not have to lose consciousness in order to have a brain injury.

In my next article on this topic, I'll share more information about brain injuries caused by car crashes, and how insurance company doctors try to pretend that the injury never occurred.



Bookmark and Share